Jesse, I agree that if Excellent books can be identified quickly they should be approved quickly. Maybe those people who carefully validate before submitting and thus submit books in Excellent condition, and they know who they are, can download, validate, and approve their own books. Since the administrators do some checking anyway before approving, that would prevent serious errors from occurring -- and if readers began to complain that books were unfairly rated excellent that a particular submitter and validated and approved, you bookshare people know who does what and can ask that that person not validate his/her own books. CIndy But surely many books really are in excellent > condition -- or have problems only in headers and > footers or where there had been charts. If these > books can be identified rather quickly, would > everyone agree they should be approved as is? > > __________________________________ Do you Yahoo!? Yahoo! Mail - 50x more storage than other providers! http://promotions.yahoo.com/new_mail