Hi Monica. I like your solution. Julia ----- Original Message ----- From: Monica Willyard To: bksvol-discuss@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Sent: Wednesday, March 03, 2010 5:28 AM Subject: [bksvol-discuss] A Temporary Solution Hi everyone. I've been thinking about Julie Carpenter's post all night. It has really bothered me because while she is correct about copyright law, Bookshare's existing tools and their words seem so out of touch with what we need to do to get books proofread. I think I have a temporary solution, the equivalent of a band-aid. It should satisfy Bookshare. Will it work for us volunteers too? You'll need to decide if it's worth doing. Under the new site where we do things now, the submitter cannot download her book to do anything to it once it's in the proofreading queue. She can't replaced garbled or missing pages, even if it would take just a minute or two. Nor can a third volunteer supply missing pages for a proofreader using the Bookshare site itself. That's why missing pages are usually emailed. How would it be if the submitter rescanned the missing content and submitted it as if it were a book, putting a hold for the proofreader in the title. It could be titled something like "Hold for Monica Missing Pages." I would know to get that file and insert its contents into the book I'm working on. Then I'd reject the submitted file that contains only the missing pages. The big downside here is that the proofreader must have an open slot on his/her queue to be able to download the file of missing pages. So it would take some deliberate planning, and people would need to really respect the holds on files so that someone's missing pages don't just disappear. This might make a little extra work for the staff, but we'd be following Bookshare's policies. It would definitely make more work for us, and that's why I say it's a temporary solution. It's a band-aid, not a permanent answer. We would need to advocate for the Bookshare developers to fix the site to let the submitter or another volunteer add missing content legally without creating a fake book. It can be done if the staff is willing to make it happen. The technology exists, so it's not like asking Bookshare to build a new site. They'd just need to change a module of code, not the entire framework. How do you feel about this solution? Is it worth a try? Monica Willyard Check out my books and accessible book lists on Goodreads at http://www.goodreads.com/profile/plumlipstick